Investigating the police: Juan Perez incident

On June 26, a videocamera at the Sarasota County Jail recorded a Sarasota police officer kicking a handcuffed suspect.

Before the department even had finished investigating possible criminal charges against the officer, the city had paid out $400 to the man who was kicked, Juan G. Perez. A Herald-Tribune reporter happened to be at Perez’s home on July 16 when a police detective drove Perez to the bank to cash the $400 check.

Combining the criminal investigation with the civil settlement violates a basic rule of police work, say legal experts who also have suggested that police officials may have broken the law.

Police Chief Peter Abbott apologized to the community, and implied that the unusually quick settlement attempt came only after the detective had taken Perez's statement for the criminal investigation. But an e-mail obtained via a public records request showed that that police considered sending a detective with a settlement offer even before beginning the criminal investigation.

The fallout includes:
• Abbott placed on paid leave on July 24;
• Sarasota City Manager Robert Bartolotta seeking an outside agency to do an administrative review;
• Six or more police offers under scrutiny; and
• Perez, 21, working with an attorney to possibly sue the city.

Recent Articles About Investigating the police: Juan Perez incident

• 

  Panel urges more oversight of police

  Published June 8, 2010
  CITY OF SARASOTA: Advisory group presents more than 60 recommendations
  

• Chief Abbott's departure

  Published May 20, 2010
  The departure of Sarasota Police Chief Peter Abbott, whose resignation Tuesday caught many observers by surprise, is a painful step but one that could help the community get past a difficult year. Unfortunately, it also means more disruption for a...
  
• 

  Abbott is out as chief in Sarasota

  Published May 19, 2010
  City Manager Bob Bartolotta said he will involve the public in the selection of the new chief, but the details are being worked out. The plan is to have a new chief hired by Dec. 1.
  

• Board member ousted over sunshine law violation

  Published April 21, 2010
  City officials say two volunteer board members violated Florida's Government-in-the-Sunshine Law during a lunch break Tuesday as they discussed the case against fired police officer Christopher Childers. The accusations were based on what a city...
  

• Punished officer has reduction of penalty

  Published April 9, 2010
  A city hearing board on Thursday reduced the punishment for a police officer who took no action after he saw another officer kick a handcuffed suspect last June. Instead of a one-day suspension, Officer Demetrios Konstantopoulos will receive a...
  

• The credibility factor

  Published February 11, 2010
  A Sarasota advisory panel is right to seek public testimony concerning police interactions with minorities. But if televised, the sessions need safeguards for credibility and accountability. The 10-member Police Advisory Panel was appointed by city...
  
• 

  Probation deal for man kicked by officer

  Published January 9, 2010
  Agreement will allow man at center of controversy to clear his record
  
• 

  Prosecutors want controversies kept out of Perez trial

  Published January 8, 2010
  The officer who arrested Juan Perez on a disorderly intoxication charge has been fired, and the Sarasota Police chief spent five months on leave over his department's handling of the arrest. But at Perez's trial on the misdemeanor charge next week,...
  
• 

  Top 10 Stories of 2009: Sarasota Edition

  Published December 30, 2009
  
  
• 

  Police get the third degree

  Published December 18, 2009
  Sarasota appointed a Police Advisory Panel in the hope of gaining thoughtful analysis from a citizen's perspective. The group got off to a bumpy start last month, but this week began to show more promise. The panel was appointed to address concerns...
  

More Investigating the police: Juan Perez incident articles from our archives